
When the Overseas Highway fills with cars headed to Key West, law enforcement takes note. During the holidays and vacation season, the Florida Highway Patrol (FHP) and local agencies step up enforcement against impaired driving, which can include sobriety checkpoints.
It’s important to know how checkpoints and other DUI stops work. If you’re charged with driving under the influence, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney before entering a plea.
Yes, DUI Checkpoints Are Legal, With Conditions
The U.S. Supreme Court held in its 1990 decision in Michigan Department of State Police v. Sitz, that a highway sobriety checkpoint program did not violate the Fourth Amendment’s protection against unreasonable searches and seizures. The opinion weighs the state’s strong interest in stopping impaired driving against the brief intrusion on motorists and concludes that the balance favors the checkpoints.
In Florida, the 1986 State v. Jones decision by the state Supreme Court ruled that police must issue written uniform guidelines before using a roadblock. That was reaffirmed in 1996 with Campbell v. State, which found a checkpoint deficient because its written plan did not adequately explain how officers would choose which vehicles to stop. These standards are still the benchmark.
In practical terms, a lawful Florida checkpoint generally needs a written operational plan, set by supervisors rather than the officers in the field. Such a plan should, at a minimum, cover the following:
- Location
- Timing
- A neutral method for selecting cars
When an agency skips those steps, evidence gathered at the checkpoint is vulnerable to legal challenge.
What Happens at a Checkpoint
Most encounters at police checkpoints are brief, as little as 30 seconds. An officer may ask for the driver’s license and registration, make observations, and either wave the car through or direct the driver to a secondary area if there are signs of impairment.
Under section 316.193 of Florida Statutes, the legal limit is a blood alcohol concentration of 0.08 for drivers aged 21 and older. Drivers under age 21 face license suspension at just 0.02 under section 322.2616.
Understand Implied Consent
Every driver on Florida roads, including out-of-state visitors, is subject to the implied consent law in section 316.1932. By driving in the state, you are considered to have agreed to a breath, blood, or urine test if lawfully arrested for DUI.
Refusing a lawful breath or urine test has consequences. A first refusal brings a one-year license suspension and, since October 1, 2025, a second-degree misdemeanor charge punishable by up to 60 days in jail and a $500 fine. If your license was previously suspended for a refusal, a second refusal brings an 18-month suspension and a first-degree misdemeanor charge punishable by up to a year in jail and a $1,000 fine.
Can You Turn Around?
If you can legally turn around to avoid a checkpoint, it’s allowed. While simply avoiding a checkpoint is not enough to justify a stop, doing so by executing an illegal U-turn, crossing a solid line in the road, or speeding away can all provide law enforcement with new reasons to pull you over. On some roads, like U.S. 1, a legal detour may not exist.
Considerations Specific to the Keys
The Overseas Highway is the only major road through the island chain south of Key Largo, resulting in heavy traffic. Monroe County Sheriff’s Officer deputies are often assigned to traffic enforcement throughout the county. Holiday enforcement campaigns often have the FHP, fish and wildlife, and county law enforcement coordinating driver screening.

Your Roadmap: Plan Ahead
The surest way to avoid trouble at a designated DUI checkpoint is to arrange a sober ride before going out, whether a designated driver, rideshare, or taxi, and to allow extra time if using U.S. 1. If you are arrested, contact Brian Casey Law promptly to speak with an experienced defense attorney because the clock on important deadlines begins immediately.
